patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!
Local Voices

Columbus was a Buffoon, and We Shouldn't Celebrate Him at All

As many of us are preparing to enjoy the long Columbus Day weekend, I find myself once again asking, “Why exactly do we still celebrate Columbus?” He wasn't American. He never made it to America. Everything he did had something wrong with it.

Sure, the guy put together an impressive expedition several centuries ago, but it’s fairly well known by now that he never even set foot in what is now the United States. He stumbled upon the Bahamas, then went to Cuba, a nation Americans can’t even legally visit today. During a later voyage came close to Panama, but that’s as close as he got to mainland North America.

He died still thinking he had found a better route to Asia.

He thought he was off the Asian coast, near India or China. China! That’s like saying you’re going to head to the Patriots game this Sunday, you end up watching sumo tournament in Tokyo, and come home and mention that Tom Brady looks fatter and less heavily padded in person.

He ran the Santa Maria aground. The guy in charge of the Pinta took off on his own unauthorized expedition. Columbus was arrested during a later expedition and stripped of his titles. One of the first things he did was to enslave some of the native population. His greatest contribution to North America was smallpox.

We take a day off to celebrate incompetence, at best.

My 12-year-old son, Brendan, is a devout anti-Columbite (I couldn’t be more proud). I remember him coming home from school the year he studied all the explorers and saying, “Why do we study this guy? He was horrible. He didn’t discover anything. There were already people here.”

He went on a roll, and I was loving it.

“I don’t even think we should take the day off. I want to go to school this day. If they open it, I’ll go in. I’m serious. He was a jerk.”

It was fantastic.

Brendan may be a bit prejudiced, but he gives St. Brendan credit for being the first European to lead an expedition to America. Did he make it? Who knows, but you can’t prove he didn’t.

In any case, he didn’t enslave anyone, crash a ship, think he was in China, or help spread a disease that killed an unknown number of people.

As for me, if we’re going to make up a holiday so we can have a long weekend, do it in August, and do it for someone better than Columbus.

If you want to learn more about Columbus (and I don’t know why you would), click here or here.

Jon McGrath grew up and lives in Westborough. You can reach him at jonmcgrath@verizon.net and follow him @JonMcGrath01581.

E

7:39 pm on Sunday, October 7, 2012

I'm a student in high school, and for years, I have been saying the same thing. I think Columbus Day is the most meaningless holiday in the history of the world. He didn't discover anything, he killed hundreds of Native Americans, and he thought he had discovered India. Yeah, lets give THIS guy a holiday.

Reply

Live and In Color

5:25 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012

So when does presidents day come off the list, that celebrates incompetence and corruption. How about all the Jewish holiday's? Those are done out appeasement. Please follow up and enlighten us on all the way's America will improve by having a small percentage of the workforce not have the day off. You may want to save pressing matters like this for Facebook.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Jon McGrath

2:20 pm on Wednesday, October 10, 2012

I'd reply to your point, but I'm not quite sure what it is. However, I don't recall saying this was a "pressing matter," nor do I believe that Patch is the New York Times; just trying to have a little fun with something.

Comment_arrow

Dan Fredonia

3:32 pm on Wednesday, October 10, 2012

Jim.....................Joe.............is that yoooooou?

Mr. Nibbles

7:45 pm on Monday, October 8, 2012

Columbus Day is a holiday because members of the teacher's union said they needed a break after the grueling transition from a three-month vacation to actually having to show up to work six hours a day. A month into the school year seemed like a good time for a well-earned breather.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Justin Saglio

11:51 am on Wednesday, October 10, 2012

South Dakota celebrates "Native American Day," they changed the name in 1990. What does everyone think about changing the holiday to celebrate Native Americans?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Ben Jackson

3:58 pm on Wednesday, October 10, 2012

There's actually already an "Indigenous People's Day" on the same day as Columbus Day. That's what my employer recognizes - and is also my preference to celebrating a slaver.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indigenous_People's_Day

Comment_arrow

Karen Adamson

10:36 am on Sunday, October 14, 2012

Good point, Justin. Many times these types of "holidays" aren't really understood and people mainly view them as a 3 day weekend get away. This one, for foliage trips.

Leave a comment